Intermittent Fasting…Yay or Nay?

 

I’ve been on the fence about intermittent fasting for a long while now.  I know people who have tried it and while I don’t want to say failed but they found it to be very difficult and eventually went back to their usual way of eating.  On the flip side I have some friends/co-workers who have made intermittent fasting a way of life. 

I’ve done some research and like what I’ve read so I’m going to give it a go. I did my first day this week while at work figuring a work day was easier than being at home with all the food.  I fasted from 6:30 pm until noon the next day. That’s 17.5 hours which is within the recommended timeframe and I’ll get to that in a minute. I found it wasn’t as hard as I anticipated even though I wasn’t as busy at work as some mornings. The hardest part was my 2, 15 minute breaks before lunch when I usually eat breakfast. Instead I filled myself up with electrolyte water and cut my breaks short. 

Why am I doing this?

Why, you might ask, am I choosing to fast? Because everything I read says it detoxes the cells, regulates cortisol (the stress hormone that, when elevated, can contribute to heart disease), lowers inflammation (which can reek havoc in the body from joints, heart, brain and so on) regulates insulin, improves gut health, improves energy and brain clarity. Need I say more? I’m trying this out for all these reasons but more specifically because I have been feeling sluggish and bloated. I feel like I need to push a reset button and I’m hoping this is it.

What is Intermittent Fasting (IF)?

For those of you who may not have heard of IF or heard of it in passing but, like me, thought “Why would anyone want to starve themselves?” Because let’s face it, as runners we generally like to eat, sometimes a lot so fasting is not in our vocabulary. Here it is in a nutshell, but I’m far from an expert on the subject so for a lot more details and information check out.The Resetter Podcast with Dr Mindy Pelz.

Intermittent fasting is an eating regimen that cycles between eating and fasting.  There are several ways to do this but the most common are these.

  • Daily fasting with the 16/8 method. This is where you fast for 16 hours then have an eating period of 8 hours. An example is to stop eating after dinner, skip breakfast then break your fast after 16 hours. People find this to be the easiest method to follow and maintain. 
  • The 5:2 method. With this approach you eat normally 5 days a week and on 2 days you eat one meal of 500 – 600 calories. This method sounds tough to me but that’s what’s good about IF, you can do what works for you.
  • 24 Fasting. Just like the name implies, you would fast for 24 hours once or twice a week, say from dinner to dinner. You could also extend this fast to 48 or 72 hours but starving for too long can trigger your body to store fat, so depending on what your goals are for IF this might be counter intuitive.

 

 What is allowed during IF?

During non eating periods you can have coffee, tea and water. Some say only black coffee while others say a small about of unsweetened creamer is okay. I’m going with the creamer. No collagen powders or protein powders but you can add electrolytes to your water. I like Nuun and LMNT.

Water
*Google images

For eating periods you can eat whatever you like, but for obvious reasons healthy foods are your best bet, preferably high in protein. Some people find salads to be hard to digest after fasting as well as some high fat foods. Soup with bone broth and soft veggies, or a fruit smoothie with protein powder are generally safe choices. Try to avoid eating every and any thing in sight…like many of us (me) tend to do when we’re starving. 

Benefits of Intermittent Fasting

  • Heart health. IM may lower blood pressure and resting heart rate (2 things us runners probably don’t need to worry about but still worth mentioning), reduce cholesterol, triglycerides, blood sugar and insulin resistance.
  • Brain function. While in the beginning you may experience some brain fog, eventually as you become accustomed to IF a brain hormone BDNF increases which may aid in forming new nerve cells and protect against Alzheimer’s.
  • Diabetes and weight loss. As mentioned previously, IM helps regulate insulin and blood sugar. Weight loss seems like a given considering you are eating less providing you’re not filling up on high calorie foods during the eating period. 
  • Increased Life Span. Studies in rats have shown fasting rats to live 36 – 83% longer. (Sources: here and here)
  • Saves money and simplifies life. Since you’re eating less there are less meals to plan which means spending less on food. I call that a win win!
  • Physical performance. Mice fed on alternate days have shown better endurance in running. (Right up our alley!) Source:John Hoskins Medicine

These are just a few of the benefits to be had with IF, there are other cellular benefits that can get quite complicated but I encourage you to listen to Dr Pelz in the link I mentioned earlier. 

Side Effects.

  • Crankiness. Let’s face it, I can get pretty hangry, but the experts say this will subside as you get use to IF. 
  • Brain fog and fatigue. Also something that will clear up after a week or two of IF.
  • Constipation. This can be an issue for many. I encourage you to push the fluids. 
Hangry
*Google images

Is IF safe for everyone?

Just like any “diet” and I hesitate to say diet because I view this more as an alternate eating regimen and the word diet seems to suggest calorie restriction, anyhow having said that, check with your primary care practitioner before starting any new alternate eating practice. For the most part IF is safe for healthy, well nourished people, but those who should avoid intermittent fasting are as follows:

  • Children and teens under 18 years old
  • Pregnant and breast feeding women.
  • People with diabetes or have trouble maintaining a healthy blood sugar.
  • Anyone with an eating disorder or are underweight.

How does IF affect me as a runner?

This has been my main concern when considering IF. Unfortunately there have not been enough studies for a definitive answer one way or another when it comes to the average runner/athlete. The few studies that have been done were with elite athletes who have longer more intense workouts and require large amounts of calories. Also the studies were done on these elite athletes during Ramadan (a Muslim practice where they only eat and drink during the dark hours). With IF you are able to consume calorie free fluids during fasting times.

On the plus side however, some studies  have suggested that glycogen stores are accessed quicker, providing fast energy for athletic performance. 

*Google images

Some helpful tips to run while fasting.

  • Time runs or workouts close to the end of a fast so you are able to eat within 30 to 60 minutes afterwards.
  • Run in the afternoon, a couple of hours after you have already broken your fast.
  • Eat plenty of protein and carbohydrates during the eating period.
  • Stay hydrated during the fasting period.
  • Just don’t fast on heavy workout days. Nothing written in stone. Some IF is better than none.
  • This is not the time to train for a marathon. Long runs need fuel before, during and after.
  • If at any time during working out you are feeling lightheaded, weak or nauseated, break your fast and take in some carbs. 

Intermittent fasting may require some trial and error to find what works for you. Or it may not work for you and life goes on. We are all trying to live our best life and this is just another avenue to explore.

I hope this information was helpful. I am not pushing Intermittent Fasting, just throwing some info out there so you can make an informed decision. As a matter of fact I don’t know yet if this will be my new lifestyle change considering I am only on my first week. We’ll see how it all works out. I’ll keep you posted. 

Have you tried IF? If so did you find a difference in how you felt?  If you haven’t tried it is it something you have considered? 

I’m linking with DeborahLisaJennLaura, and Debbie for

As always thanks for reading!

                     Denise 

 

21 COMMENTS

  1. runswithpugs | 10th Jun 21

    Good luck! I’ve had a lot of friends be very successful with IF.

    I’m recovered from an ED, so I tend not to try anything that restricts me or requires me to count, measure, or otherwise monitor my intake. The spiral starts quickly for me, and I know it’s not in my best interests.

    • Denise | 10th Jun 21

      I’m glad you’re recovered and are aware of what’s best for you. Stay well Jenn.

  2. Catrina | 10th Jun 21

    Thank you for this information, Denise!
    I have read some articles on Mark’s Daily Apple on IF and I have always been wanting to try it.
    I think I will try this out next week. I’d be very interested to know how it will work our for you in the upcoming weeks!

    • Denise | 10th Jun 21

      I’ll post and update later in the month. Good luck if you give it a try. I’ll have to check out those articles.

  3. deborahbrooks14 | 10th Jun 21

    I have tried it and it’s not for me. I don’t have enough energy for my workouts fasted and just did not feel great. I know there are so many people who love it. You have to find what works best for you and run with it! Keep us posted on how it goes

    • Denise | 10th Jun 21

      Yeah I think it’s tricky with working out. I might try skipping dinner so I can have food in the morning. I probably should’ve tried this in the winter when I can run later in the day without the heat.

  4. Lisa | 10th Jun 21

    I didn’t know much about this so thanks for sharing. I think I would struggle to have enough energy. I hope it goes well for you!

    • Denise | 10th Jun 21

      I’m feeling okay but it’s only been 3 days and today was my first day running. And I don’t have a toddler. 😊

  5. Darlene | 10th Jun 21

    Thanks for the information. I hope it works for you.

    I don’t think it work for me though.

    • Denise | 10th Jun 21

      I’m not sure if it will work for me either but I’m going to give it a fair try.

  6. Marcia | 11th Jun 21

    I’ve studied up on IF and tried two 6-week stints of it. All that said, it is not for me. While I regularly ran in a fasted state in my 40s, doing so after menopause caused a massive cortisol spike, resulting in unwanted belly fat, now that I don’t have the estrogen levels to buffer it. I later learned that fasting is not a good idea for those of us with autoimmune disease.

    • Denise | 11th Jun 21

      Good to know. I didn’t read anything about autoimmune disease and IF. I don’t want to put any misinformation out there.
      We’ll see if I can do this.

  7. LoseWeightWithAng | 13th Jun 21

    Because I’ve suffered with eating disorders, I stay away from food restrictions, which I’m happy to see you recommend. But I have heard IF has been helpful to many people. I’d love to see it work for you.

    • Denise | 13th Jun 21

      I’m glad you are able to recognize what is healthy or unhealthy for you. I would never want anyone to follow any eating plan that puts them in an unhealthy situation. Stay well.

  8. Laura Norris Running | 15th Jun 21

    I hope it goes well for you! There is substantial research out there that low energy availability has a very negative effect on metabolic function, hormonal response, and performance in athletes – and increases risk of injury (https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-020-00275-6). Some researchers debate if the effects it has on mice and other animals translate to humans, nor do we understand the long-term effects of IF. Without clear evidence, it’s something I would be hesitant to try it. But I also like food!

    • Denise | 15th Jun 21

      That’s quite the article. It gives me a lot to think about.
      I like food too! 🙂

  9. Chocolaterunsjudy | 19th Jun 21

    I’ve tried a kindler, gentler version — more like 14 hour fasts. Which isn’t so much when you think about it. It never really seemed to do much for me, and like Marcia, I’ve read the benefits are not as great when you’re menopausal — although I don’t have an autoimmune disease, knock on wood.

    Good luck! It will be interesting to read about your experiences.

    • Denise | 19th Jun 21

      Yeah 14 hour fast is much easier. I’m not sure if it’s affecting my energy or it’s this darn humidity.

      • Chocolaterunsjudy | 19th Jun 21

        Humidity definitely makes me tired. We enjoyed some great weather this week until today!

        14 hours is definitely easier. I typically have dinner around 6 & then breakfast around 9. Just depends though. I’m not trying for ketosis so if I’m hungrier earlier I just eat.

        For a while I was trying it out more seriously but didn’t really see much benefit for me. I do think it’s a good idea to let our digestive system have a break sometimes though!

  10. Sumit Singh | 26th Jun 21

    Nice article, Denise. You have covered many important things related to intermittent fasting. Intermittent fasting works only if you do it correctly and consistently. Your experience will help many people. Thank you very much for this article. Keep posting such articles in the future also.

    • Denise | 28th Jun 21

      Thanks for reading. I’m doing my best at being consistent.

Leave A Comment

Tell me what you think...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.